For best experience please turn on javascript and use a modern browser!

When Should a Case Be Dismissed? The Economics of Pleading and Summary Judgment Standards

Event details of May 22, 2006: Keith Hylton (Boston University)
Date 22 May 2006
Time 11:45 -13:15


This paper applies a simple economic framework to the choice between pleading and summary judgment as points at which a claim can be dismissed. It concludes generally that pleading standards should vary with the evidentiary demands of the associated legal standards and the social costs of litigation. The common law’s imposition of higher pleading standards for fraud claims is consistent with this proposition. The theory implies that the rigorous summary
judgment standards that have been developed by antitrust courts should lead to a correspondingly rigorous assessment at the pleading stage.


Oudemanhuispoort 4-6
1012 CN Amsterdam